US vs UK Universities: A Full Comparison For Hong Kong Students
Feeling swamped by the multitude of options and concerned about selecting the "right" university? Fear not! In this blog post, we'll delve into the 7 key factors that differentiate US vs UK universities, providing you with essential insights to make an informed decision about your educational future.
As a high school student in Hong Kong, deciding on the best university pathway for your future can be a daunting task. While UK universities are often a popular choice due to their prestigious academic reputation and the familiarity of the British education system, it's crucial not to overlook the potential advantages of attending a US university. By examining both US and UK university systems, you may discover that one aligns more closely with your personal aspirations and goals.
Key Differences Between US and UK Universities
While the US and UK offer a variety of options when it comes to studying at some of the finest institutions around the world. Here are some highlights of each education system to help you decide which path is best for you:
US vs UK Universities
| US Education System | UK Education System | Both Education Systems |
|---|---|---|
| - Flexibility due to a unique liberal arts education - A wide range of clubs, activities, and extracurriculars - Various scholarships and financial aid opportunities - Ability to compete athletically at an elite level with recruitment & scholarships | - A focused and in-depth approach to learning - Financial assistance less significant due to lower costs - Shorter path to some professions (e.g. law, medicine) - The tutorial system at top UK universities such as Oxford and Cambridge | - Unrivaled resources and professors at top universities - Global reputation and recognition as leaders in higher education - Access to elite graduate and internship opportunities Extensive alumni network and low student:faculty ratio |
1. Are you more of an ‘all-rounder’ or a ‘scholar’?
Academics are the first criteria admissions officers consider when determining who gets a spot on campus. Top universities want to ensure that the students they select will be well-prepared for a demanding learning environment.
Academics account for approximately 40% of your US application; and in the UK, it's about 75%!
In general, US universities seek 'all-rounders': students who possess a combination of leadership qualities, intelligence, creativity, and initiative. Meanwhile, UK universities seek 'scholars': capable academics who are passionate, rigorous, and resilient.
2. How long does it take to complete a degree?
Bachelor’s Degree
In the UK, a bachelor's degree usually takes three years, while in the US it takes four years, which is similar to Hong Kong.
Master’s Degree
It usually takes just a year to complete a master's degree in the UK, whereas it takes two years in the US.
While the UK does not offer much financial aid compared to the US, their educational institutions are generally less expensive. As most UK universities take three years to complete an undergraduate degree as opposed to four in the US, this reduces the cost of undergraduate education drastically from tuition to living expenses. More on that later!
3. How many universities can you apply to?
The UK application portal called University and Colleges Admissions Service (UCAS) limits students to a maximum of five universities and/or courses. In other words, you could apply for up to five courses at only one university or college, or five different courses at five different universities. Plus, you can only apply to one elite university - either Oxford or Cambridge - at one time.
Meanwhile, the US Common App allows students to apply to as many universities as they want, and each university has its own deadlines, application requirements, etc.
However, just because you could, doesn’t mean you should!
We recommend making a list of target, reach, and safety schools.
Our US college admissions calculator or UK university admissions calculator can help you narrow down your search for the right university!
4. How are universities structured?
US Universities
Students at US universities typically spend four years as an undergraduate where they mostly study liberal arts degrees and science and engineering programs. As part of their commitment to providing students with a broad and comprehensive education, most US universities do not require their students to select a 'major', or area of study, until they are in their second year.
Courses in liberal arts are interdisciplinary and cover a wide range of topics, allowing students to explore different academic avenues in order to expand their knowledge in chosen subjects and discover hidden passions prior to selecting a major.
Additionally, students can take 'minors' or 'certificates' in other areas of study to complement their majors and add diversity to their final two years at college.
UK Universities
The UK educational system places more emphasis on in-depth knowledge in a specific area of study, with undergraduate programs typically lasting three years. While they are more traditional and less concerned with a student’s non-academic pursuits, they do want to see evidence of a student’s passion — what matters to them and why, and how they intend to pursue these passions to make academic progress and contribute to the university in question.
Particularly at Oxford and Cambridge, the tutorial system takes this desire to examine a specific area of study in great detail to a new and highly individualized level. In their weekly tutorials, which are often as small as one faculty member to three or four students, students have an opportunity to learn, enquire, share, and discuss their thoughts and ideas with leaders in their chosen field.
Oxbridge offers unrivaled access to top professors in small group settings, while students at top universities in the US have to seek out these kinds of learning opportunities more proactively.
However, students in the US may benefit from a more peer-focused learning environment and more steady, frequent assessments. Regardless, if you thrive in more intimate learning settings, then it’s important to prioritize smaller universities both in the US and UK.
5. What is the difference in personal essays/statements?
Well-written essays play a key role in any successful application to the world's best universities. The Common App essay tends to be more reflective, creative, and personal, whereas the UCAS personal statement is more academic and course-specific.
US universities also require individual Supplemental Essays. The Common App prompts are the standard questions that every school you apply to gets answers for — but the supplemental questions represent an individual university’s best chance to get to know you further and judge whether or not you’ll be a good fit on their campus.
US Common App vs UK Personal Statement
| US Common App | UK Personal Statement |
|---|---|
| Focuses on insight and takeaways from an experience — rather than the experience itself. Successful essays are often humble and reflect a student's capacity to struggle with, and conquer, difficult concepts (rather than implying that the student is already an expert). Students should not be afraid to admit their mistakes, show how mentors inspired them, or celebrate their resilience in times of indecision or hardship. | Reflects your history of engagement in your chosen course subject and illustrates an intellectual passion and curiosity for the student's area of interest, as well as a desire to continue to explore new aspects of their chosen area of study. This essay further demonstrates a student's ability to reflect upon their life experiences, learn from their mistakes and map out a path towards a successful, productive future. |
6. Are Extracurricular Activities Important?
US Universities
With applicant pools growing larger and more competitive each year, US admissions officers now look for 'well-rounded' students' who display a mix of intelligence and discipline through their academic performance as well as creativity, resourcefulness, and authenticity through their unique extracurricular activities.
Most US universities use the Common Application, which includes a dedicated Activities List for students to describe their extracurricular and leadership activities in order of importance. As a general rule, you’ll want to start by listing your most meaningful and impressive activities first.
- Check out our free eBook on Ultimate Guide to Competitive Hong Kong-Based Extracurricular & Leadership Activities
UK Universities
Meanwhile, UK universities place less emphasis on extracurricular activities and value your ‘Supercurriculars’ more — things you do to explore subjects and develop your academic skills beyond your school studies. This includes reading, podcasts, online courses, research, relevant work experience or volunteer work, writing, projects, debating, and other activities revolving around your academic interests.
What matters most for UK applicants is that you add depth to your Supercurriculars! While you may have impressive-sounding achievements in your personal statement, failing to explain what you have learned from an experience or providing your own reflections and insights can work against you.
- Check out our free eBook on Supercurriculars: Boosting Your Application for Top UK Universities
7. How much does it cost to go to university?
US Universities
The maximum cost per year at a top university without financial aid is approximately HK$540,000 including all education and residency costs.
However, the great majority of students on campus receive some form of financial aid.
For example, at Harvard, where international students receive the same financial aid as citizens, 70% of students receive some form of financial aid.
International students receive financial aid primarily through scholarships, grants, and private student loans from specific colleges. The availability of these awards will depend on the school's admission (need-blind or need-aware policies) and aid policies for international students, so it is important to do your research.
International students can also seek out scholarships from private foundations and other organizations dedicated to supporting study in the US.
UK Universities
While financial aid and scholarships to UK universities are rare compared to their US counterparts, the education itself is less expensive averaging somewhere between HK$102,000 - HK$307,000 with Oxford and Cambridge at the upper end of the spectrum. Additionally, most UK degrees take three years as opposed to the US’s four-year undergraduate structure. This means the costs are spread across three not four years of tuition and residency.
In regards to financial aid, each university in the UK has its own policies on aid and other assistance. In saying that, funding for some UK institutions is available and Crimson Education consultants can provide further information on which schools are more conducive to international student financial assistance compared to others.
Crimson Education also offers a range of scholarships to students, check out our scholarships page for more information.
Final Thoughts
Both US and UK universities provide an extensive range of disciplines and each institution has its own unique culture and environment as highlighted above.
Regardless of where you go, studying overseas will open many doors for you, there's no doubt about that.
We hope this blog post has helped you understand the various aspects of applying to top US and UK universities, and how you can strengthen your candidacy to compete against other highly qualified applicants.
Looking for personalized assistance in the admissions process? At Crimson Education, we help narrow down the options for each individual student. In fact, the ‘best fit’ philosophy is key to Crimson’s personalized approach to overseas university acceptance.
Crimson brings a new level of personalization, and therefore results, to the application process — increasing students' chances of admission to the Ivy League, Oxbridge, and other top US and UK universities by up to 600%.
Our admissions experts can help you in every step of your admissions journey, from university selection strategy, test prep and personal statement/essay support, to extracurricular project mentoring, interview practice, and tutoring.
Schedule a free one-hour consultation with a Crimson Academic Advisor, who can help you chart your path to success!
What Makes Crimson Different