Are College Consultants Worth It?

Lessons learned from working with over 3,000 students

As Seen in the Wall Street Journal

Do college consultants really make a difference—and are they worth it?

Featured on the front page of The Wall Street Journal, Crimson Education helps students boost their chances of getting into Ivy League and Top 10 schools by 6.75x. We analyzed thousands of applications to uncover the real impact of expert consulting—and whether it’s worth the investment.

wsj-thumbnail_1

Why More Families Are Seeking Help

The college admissions process isn’t what it used to be. Today, it’s more competitive and far more high-stakes.

For many families, it feels like trying to win a game where the rules keep changing. Parents are expected to help their kids: - Choose the “right” classes as early as 9th grade - Build standout extracurricular profiles - Create a balanced college list across selectivity tiers - Navigate early decision, essays, testing, financial aid, and interviews It’s no wonder more families are turning to experts to level the playing field.

us-admissions_student_talia_upenn

“At Harvard, 23% of freshmen in 2023 reported using a private admissions advisor. For students from families earning over $500,000, that number jumps to 48%.”

The Wall Street Journal

background image

What a College Consultant Actually Does

A great college consultant is more than an essay editor—they’re a strategist, mentor, and project manager who keeps the entire process on track. They bring structure, clarity, and calm to an otherwise overwhelming journey.

01

Map out high school with purpose—choosing courses, shaping extracurriculars, picking research projects, and setting long-term goals early.

02

Go beyond rankings. Identify schools that fit academically, socially, and financially—with a smart mix of reach, target, and safety options.

03

Guide every piece of the application—essays, recommendations, testing, and interviews—so each works together to tell a compelling story.

04

Turn passions into standout achievements with activities that align with the student’s interests and ambitions.

05

Find and apply for competitive programs (often with early deadlines) that strengthen the student’s academic narrative.

06

Keep everything on track with regular check-ins, clear timelines, and a structured plan—reducing stress for students and parents alike.

Ready to Start Your Journey to Your Dream University?

Fill out the form below and a Crimson representative will be in touch with you to book a free meeting with one of our expert advisors!

Why Crimson?

A Team of Specialists—Not Just One Counselor

At Crimson, you don’t rely on a single consultant for every aspect of your application. Instead, you get a dedicated team—from essay mentors and extracurricular strategists to interview coaches—each a specialist in their field, all working together to maximize your success.

about-us_two-crimson-consultants_noah-and-kevin

Numbers Don't Lie

Proven Success. Unmatched Results.

7x

Our Crimson students get into the Ivy league and other Top 15 colleges at over 7x the general applicant rate.

Total Offers to the Ivy League

College-Specific Acceptance Rates

Top CollegesGeneral Admit RateCrimson Admit Rate
Harvard3.7%20%
Stanford3.6%30.8%
Yale4.6%26.7%
Columbia4.3%32.7%
UPenn5.4%39.7%
Dartmouth6%50%
Princeton4.4%28.3%
Cornell8.4%55.9%
MIT4.5%26.1%

98%

98% of our students are admitted to at least one of their top five college choices.

These Crimson Students Got In

Your child can, too.

Accepted to

Stanford

Testimonial
name

Holly C.

major

Medicine

“Aidan was my strategist and he helped me significantly by directing which activities I should be doing, how to frame them in my application and matching me with a great essay counselor.”

“Aidan was my strategist and he helped me significantly by directing which activities I should be doing, how to frame them in my application and matching me with a great essay counselor.”

Holly C.

Accepted to

UCLA

Testimonial
name

Jin T.

major

Engineering

“Jennifer was my essay mentor and she was just great. Whether sparking new ideas during the brainstorming process or looking over my finished draft for redundant words and ideas, she clarified the focus needed for specific essay prompts.”

“Jennifer was my essay mentor and she was just great. Whether sparking new ideas during the brainstorming process or looking over my finished draft for redundant words and ideas, she clarified the focus needed for specific essay prompts.”

Jin T.

Accepted to

Wharton (Upenn)

Testimonial
name

James N.

major

Undecided

“Jordan was my strategist and I know I could not have gotten into Wharton without his help. They helped me understand exactly what I needed to do.”

“Jordan was my strategist and I know I could not have gotten into Wharton without his help. They helped me understand exactly what I needed to do.”

James N.

Accepted to

Cornell

Testimonial
name

Alex R.

major

Undecided

“George was my Strategist. He helped curate a college list that would help with my ambitions as a scholar, athlete, and overall person. Above all, however, he wanted to make my dreams a reality and encouraged me. ”

“George was my Strategist. He helped curate a college list that would help with my ambitions as a scholar, athlete, and overall person. Above all, however, he wanted to make my dreams a reality and encouraged me. ”

Alex R.

Accepted to

John Hopkins

Testimonial
name

Ziyan L.

major

Medicine

“The best part about working with Crimson was how incredibly knowledgeable everyone on the team was. It gave me a lot of confidence during the application process.”

“The best part about working with Crimson was how incredibly knowledgeable everyone on the team was. It gave me a lot of confidence during the application process.”

Ziyan L.

Accepted to

Cornell

Testimonial
name

Jaelyn C.

major

Animal Science

“Crimson helped me strengthen my mindset and approach to the application process. Their guidance gave me the confidence and support I needed to stay focused on my goals.”

“Crimson helped me strengthen my mindset and approach to the application process. Their guidance gave me the confidence and support I needed to stay focused on my goals.”

Jaelyn C.

The Knowledge Network

Meet Our Experts

Crimson’s admissions counselors include an impressive lineup of Former Admissions Officers from the Ivy League and several other Top 10 and 20 universities, including Stanford, Duke, Johns Hopkins, Northwestern, and more.

Profile background
Devery D

Devery D

Former Harvard Admissions Officer

Devery brings a rare level of insight and institutional knowledge to the Crimson team, having studied higher education management at Harvard's Graduate School of Education in addition to serving as a Harvard admissions officer, UC Berkeley application reader, and an application reader for a top liberal arts college.

Profile background
Kimberley L.

Kimberley L.

Former Stanford Admissions Officer

A former admissions officer at Northwestern and Stanford and a graduate of Wellesley, Kellogg, and Oxford, Kimberley brings a holistic perspective to helping students and families navigate the college admissions process.

Profile background
Dana C.

Dana C.

Senior Strategy Consultant

Dana Crum is a Princeton graduate, former application reader in Princeton University's Office of Undergraduate Admission, and a seasoned admissions consultant with a decade of success guiding domestic and international students into top US, UK and Canadian universities.

Crimson Alumni are now working at top global companies

Stripe
Space Tech
Airwallex
Financial Times
Adobe
NHS
AWS
Paraform
The Vein Institute
Beacon
AHN
Dentons
Perennial Partners
NASA
Waymo
Quora
Google
Unicef
Goldman Sachs
Y Combinator
Bridgewater
Deepmind
McKinsey & Comapny
Stripe
Space Tech
Airwallex
Financial Times
Adobe
NHS
AWS
Paraform
The Vein Institute
Beacon
AHN
Dentons
Perennial Partners
NASA
Waymo
Quora
Google
Unicef
Goldman Sachs
Y Combinator
Bridgewater
Deepmind
McKinsey & Comapny
Stripe
Space Tech
Airwallex
Financial Times
Adobe
NHS
AWS
Paraform
The Vein Institute
Beacon
AHN
Dentons
Perennial Partners
NASA
Waymo
Quora
Google
Unicef
Goldman Sachs
Y Combinator
Bridgewater
Deepmind
McKinsey & Comapny
Stripe
Space Tech
Airwallex
Financial Times
Adobe
NHS
AWS
Paraform
The Vein Institute
Beacon
AHN
Dentons
Perennial Partners
NASA
Waymo
Quora
Google
Unicef
Goldman Sachs
Y Combinator
Bridgewater
Deepmind
McKinsey & Comapny

Book a free consultation with one of our expert advisors.